For today’s theme of EYABeginning, Hannah Salisbury takes us through the project Grounds for Appeal: First World War Military Service Appeal Tribunals in Great Britain.
On 29th September 1916 38-year-old George Hook of Bury St Edmunds in Suffolk appeared before a panel of his fellow townsmen. They were charged with deciding whether he should remain at home, working as a foreman bricklayer, or be conscripted for military service.
When conscription was introduced in 1916, a system by which men or their employers could appeal against it was set up. Over 2,800 Military Service Tribunals across the country reviewed the applications. Their job was to balance recruitment into the army with the needs of the local economy; there was no point in conscripting all men if there was no one left behind to mine coal, forge steel, or grow food.

The case of George Hook
The panel that George appeared in front of was the Bury St Edmunds Military Service Tribunal. George’s employer had applied to them to ask for George to be exempted from compulsory military service. The employer argued that George’s work was of national importance, and there was a severe shortage of skilled men to replace him. Moreover, he had three brothers already serving in the army, as was his 19-year-old step-son Bertram. The Tribunal decided they could not exempt George, and he duly joined the Suffolk Regiment.
Just two weeks after this hearing, George’s step-son Bertram was killed in France.
George himself was wounded twice and eventually captured. He survived the war and returned home to Bury St Edmund, picking up his work as a bricklayer.
Surviving records
This story has come to light through studying the records of the Bury St Edmunds Military Service Tribunal, which heard 1,213 cases between 1916 and 1918. They are rare survivors; in 1922, the government gave permission for Tribunal records to be destroyed, and most local authorities happily burnt them.
Over the last 15 or so years we have realised that more of these records survive than previously thought. Some must have been deliberately preserved, others perhaps are accidental survivors.


Several archives have previously run local projects to index and research their local Tribunal records. Grounds for Appeal is bringing together many of these existing databases, harmonising them, and adding new material which has never been indexed. It is a combined cataloguing and research project which will enable researchers to access and explore these records like never before.
A Grounds for Appeal database
The database we are building will be published on a dedicated website by early 2028. We anticipate that the database will be useful to people researching individual people (e.g. for family history), but also to researchers who want to approach the data in other ways (e.g. looking at particular occupations or domestic circumstances).
The project is led by Wiltshire and Swindon History Centre, who have a significant amount of surviving Tribunal records. We have a small central project team (me as Project Co-ordinator, Dr Angus Wallace as Historical Adviser, Naomi Oakley as Project Lead, and Nell Farrally as Evaluator). The central team create resources and support each partner archive in their local project delivery.
The intention is that this approach brings benefits both in project delivery and outcomes. Having the central team to create tools and resources saves time for the partner archives, and results in a consistent approach making the data easier to analyse. Working together, we are able to spot patterns, problem solve, and pool expertise to make sense of these sometimes complex records.

What does the data say?
The above picture is the first (of many) graphs from the data, comparing the grounds for appeal used in Bury St Edmunds in Suffolk and Aysgarth in North Yorkshire. We can see that ground A, that a man was already doing work of national importance, was the most used ground in both locations. However, there are big differences around ground D, that military service would causes serious hardship, with this being used much more in Bury St Edmunds than Aysgarth, and ground G, which is that a man was in an exempted occupation, which was used much more in Aysgarth than Bury St Edmunds. The two were very different places, Bury St Edmunds being a market town and Aysgarth being a rural farming community. This different socio-economic composition may explain these differences.
Hopefully, this project can be the beginning of this sort of approach being applied to future archive projects. It is also hopefully the beginning of widening public access to these fascinating records, and the beginning of opportunities to better understand this significant and long-obscured part of life in the First World War.
Further information
You can find out more about the project, and some of the stories we have uncovered so far, on our Substack: https://wwigroundsforappeal.substack.com/
Grounds for Appeal is made possibly by a grant from the National Lottery Heritage Fund.
Written by Hannah Salisbury, Project Coordinator for Grounds for Appeal: First World War Military Service Appeal Tribunals in Great Britain.
Edited by Isabel Lauterjung, Blog Coordinator for Explore Your Archive.


